Jim Spellman/WireImage When it came time to cast the younger version of Ana Gasteyer‘s character, Sheila Shay, for Wednesday’s episode of Suburgatory, producers didn’t have to look very far.

SNL alums look back on Olympian who was booked to host and then didn't medal: 'My favorite host of all time' Ana Gasteyer once caught Jimmy Carter 'laughing hysterically' at Dan Aykroyd's SNL ...

How many Broadway shows has Ana Gasteyer been in? Ana Gasteyer has appeared on Broadway in 7 shows. How many West End shows has Ana Gasteyer been in? Ana Gasteyer has not appeared in the West End.