Buckeyes, or peanut butter balls, are an indulgent chocolatey and peanut butter fudgy treat. We reckon there's only one type of peanut butter that works best.

Wegmans' peanut butter was tasty and notably denser than the others I tried. Its texture reminded me of Jif peanut butter because it was thick and a little less creamy than I prefer. Still ...

After decades of growth, America's favorite peanut butter hit tough times. Undermined by private label and outspent by rivals, sales slipped into decline. At the same time, Jif was losing pre-family ...