After skating around a frigid ice rink, making snowballs and analyzing several pairs of everyday winter gloves, I found two winners that I’ll turn to the next time it snows.

I snowboarded with eight pairs of heated gloves, ran temperature tests and held them under the sink to find the very best. These two pairs are the clear winners.

There’s no cold-weather accessory that helps get you through a blustery winter like warm gloves. To find the best winter gloves for women—whether you’re commuting, shoveling snow, skiing or running ...