Our opinionated staffers gathered to taste test 11 brands of balsamic vinaigrette. Here’s the best salad dressing we tasted.

For basic salad dressings, I use apple cider vinegar or white balsamic vinegar—they’re mild and have a hint of sweetness built in. If I’m feeling fancy, I reach for aged sherry vinegar.

Balsamic delivers a rich taste while maintaining the acidic kick of vinegar. Commonly seen in glazes, dressings, and reductions, it’s a staple of Italian dishes and has long been recognized as a ...